Thank you for attending the Webinar on “A Green Agriculture Model for Sri Lanka: Busting Myths and Investing on the Reality” held on 05th June 2021. Hope that was helpful for you. If you missed anything at the event, the following is the youtube link to the video.

  1. “Myths and Reality about Impact of Agrochemicals on Human Health: A Public Health Perspective” – by Prof Indika Karunathilake
  2. “Potential of Organic and Inorganic Fertilizers in Providing Nutrients for Agricultural Systems in Sri Lanka” – by Prof Saman Dharmakeerthi
  3. “Impact of pesticides on crop protection in Sri Lanka: The need, challenges, and prospects” – by Dr Lionel Nugaliyadde
  4. “Economic Effects of the Agrochemical Import Ban” – by Prof Jeevika Weerahewa
  5. “Good Agriculture Practices (GAP) as the Stepping Stone for the Green Agriculture Model” – by Mr Amal Arunapriya

Summary of Outcome of the Webinar jointly organized by Sri Lanka Institute of Agriculture and the Organization of Professional Associations of Sri Lanka

Summary of Outcome of the Webinar jointly organized by Sri Lanka Institute of Agriculture
and the Organization of Professional Associations of Sri Lanka

Import Ban on Chemical Fertilizers: Busting Myths and Investing on Reality

The summary is prepared based on the presentations made by Professor Indika Karunatillake,
Professor Saman Dharmakeerthi, Professor Jeevika Weerahewa and Mr. Amal Arunapriya.
Preamble:

  • A perusal of the economic size, employment, income and expenditure, consumption and
    trade pattern of Sri Lanka reveals that crop agriculture, which will directly be affected by
    the import ban, plays an important and special role in the agri-food economy of Sri Lanka.
  • The contribution of agriculture to the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) was 7% and that of
    crop agriculture was 5% in 2020. Out of the labour force, 25% was in agriculture sector of
    which tea, rice and vegetables provided the highest contribution in 2019. Of the income
    sources of households, 8% is from agriculture and of expenditure, 35% is spent on food
    and 92%, 67%, and 74% of calories, protein and fat respectively are from vegetable
    products in 2016. Tea, vegetables and fruits are the key crop agriculture exports of Sri
    Lanka.

Recent Policy Directive on Banning Importation of Chemical Fertilizer and Pesticides

  • The National Policy Document “Vistas of Prosperity and Splendor”, aims at revolutionizing
    the fertilizer use in the country in order to build a community of healthy and productive
    citizens. Hence, production of foods without contamination of agro-chemicals have been
    given the priority.
  • Chemical fertilizers are an important input as a source of plant nutrients and chemical
    pesticides are damage control agents for pests and diseases in agricultural production
    systems. Hence, the imposition of the import ban to halt the imports of chemical fertilizers
    and pesticides into Sri Lanka with effect of May 6, 2021 has created myriad of concerns
    among an array of stakeholders on its economic effects.
  • In this connection, the government of Sri Lanka has recently declared and established a
    Task Force to transform Sri Lanka into a Green Socio-economy with Sustainable Solutions
    for Climate Changes.

Issues of concern:

Food and nutrition safety is one of the major concerns in Sri Lanka as at present. There is
an increasing demand for safe and healthy food from the consumers at global scale. There
is an increasing need for a mechanism that minimize the misuse of agro-chemicals and
make use of natural resources in a sustainable manner while enhancing the organic matter
production, and protection of human health, safety and welfare of workers.
2

Sri Lanka is currently facing the double burden of Malnutrition. In one hand, there is under
nutrition and nutritional deficiencies among the children under the age of 5 years where
17% are underweight for their age, 11.2% are stunted, 13% suffer from acute malnutrition
(wasting) and 2.3% suffer from severe acute malnutrition. On the other hand, 25% of Sri
Lankan adults is overweight and one 10% is obese.

Heavy metal(oid)s present in TSP, especially Cd and As has been linked by some to CKDu
prevalence of some Dry Zone areas of Sri Lanka.

Likelihood of applying excess P contents in the soils leading to a environmental pollution
such as eutrophication and cynotoxicity in the long run.
Myths and reality

Myth 1: “Western Knowledge is not suitable for Sri Lanka”
Knowledge is a growing and evolving body. There is nothing called “eastern
science” and “Western science”. Scientific method is evolving.

Myth 2: “Plant products without using agrochemicals are safe food”
Safety of the food has to ensured at all levels of the food flow; growing, harvesting,
transport and delivery, storage and preservation, purchasing, preparation, cooking,
holding, serving and storage

Myth 3: “We were much healthier without using chemicals” and that “Natural products
are not carcinogenic”

Anything used inappropriately can be carcinogenic, e.g. Sunlight (UV rays) and plant
toxins. There is a need for screening, monitoring and regulations

Myth 4: “Organic fertilizers are safer than agrochemicals”
Developing organic fertilizers is essentially a biological process and presence of
Micro biome is unavoidable. Possibility of presence of inorganic material such as
heavy metals cannot be ruled out. The need for using larger quantities makes
monitoring even more difficult.
Myth 6: “Imported food items are safer than locally available” and “Traditional Dietary
Patterns are Always Healthy”
There are many positive aspects in traditional practices. Traditions and Culture
evolve with time. For example: traditionally Sri Lankan farmers consume large
amounts of carbohydrates. This may not be appropriate for current context.
Similarly, vegetables and fruits less than 5% eat minimum amount Energy and
nutrient intakes among Sri Lankan adults. Increased intake of fruits and vegetables
is the main strategy of weight loss, and reduce blood glucose and CVD in SL
 Myth 7: CKDu is caused by Cadmium (Cd) and Arsenic (As) found in chemical fertilizers as
contaminants:
When paddy fields are considered, application of chemical fertilizers will add only
very minute quantity of Cd (0.3 g per 2 million kg of soil) and As (2 g per 2 million
kg of soil) to the paddy soils. Two research groups, Prof Rohana Chandrajith and coworkers and Prof. Mangala De Silva and co-workers (please see
3
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envint.2020.106019 and https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
jtemb.2019. 04.019) independently verified that drinking waters in the dry zone of
Sri Lanka has these metal(oid)s in concentrations less than the permissible levels
recommended by the World Health Organization (WHO). Hence, the cause-result
relationship between the occurrence of CKDu and heavy metal from chemical
fertilizers cannot be established.
 Myth 8: chemical fertilizers are used excessively in Sri Lanka.
According to FAOSTAT data base (2021), it is clearly evident that the fertilizer usage
in the country has been decreased since 2013 to levels that are comparable to India
and Australia. Other neigboring countries are using higher rates of chemical
fertilizers than Sri Lanka while the European countries apply 5 to 10 fold higher
rates of chemical fertilizers to their soils.
Furthermore, fertilizer imports for paddy cultivation in Sri Lanka is done and
distributed by the two Government-owned fertilizer companies. The quantities are
based on the estimates provided by the Department of Agriculture and the
Department of Agrarian Development. Therefore, fertilizer import quantities to Sri
Lanka are based on the estimated requirement and hence, excessive use cannot be
justified at a higher level of confidence.
 Myth 9: Composts, poultry manure, and cow-dung are organic “fertilizers”.
These materials are not recommended as fertilizers but as soil amendments or
conditioners that improve soil fertility parameters such as organic carbon content,
nutrient and water holding capacities, increasing biological activity in soil and
binding of toxic elements in soil to name a few. The nutrient content in these
materials and their ratios are not suitable for providing plant nutrients for various
soil-crop systems.
Production Losses:
 Because these conventional fertilizers are poor source of plant nutrient, field crop
experiments conducted by using them, often have resulted yield losses, despite using huge
quantities of such fertilizers.
A loss of 24% paddy with 10 t organic matter /ha, 13-60% loss of vegetables with 20 to 40
tons of compost/ha, 10-45%of of vegetables with 20 – 40 tons of cattle manure/ha have
been recorded.
Disappearance of chemical fertilizers and pesticides from agricultural systems would also
create 25% yield loss in cinnamon and even 100% loss in floriculture, foliage and vegetables
in controlled environments.
Unavailability of Organic Matter
 A total ban of chemical fertilizer, will demand production of very large quantities of organic
manures to provide the required quantities of nutrients to crops. It has been estimated
that at least to provide the nutrient quantities that are removed from agricultural systems
4
as yield, about 18 million tons of compost is required (assuming NPK ratio is 1.5-0.5-1,
contains 10% moisture and 50% efficiency) for crops such as paddy, corn, potato, tea and
coconut.
 The registered suppliers with Department Agriculture can produce 0.3 million tons,
National Fertilizer Secretariat registered suppliers could produce another 0.5 million tons
of compost. Through the solid organic wastes generated in different Pradeshiya Sabha and
municipal/urban councils (ca. 3500 tons per day) another 0.3 million could be produced.
Still the country cannot produce the required quantities to provide plant nutrient losses as
yield.
Threat of heavy metal contamination of soils through import of organic fertilizers
 Application of large quantities of conventional organic manures has another inherent
problem associated with it. They also contains heavy metals, in additions to the treats of
antibiotics, micro-plastics, poly aromatic hydrocarbons, weed seeds and even pathogens
(if not correctly produced).
 Assuming application of 5 tons of compost per ha for a season, about 26 years of Pb, 20
years of Cr and 11 years of Cd applies as chemical fertilizers would be applied within one
season (assuming these chemical on organics contain maximum allowable concentrations).
In the case of locally produced organic manures, it is re-distribution of heavy metals
already present in Sri Lanka into farmer fields. If we were to import organic fertilizers to
meet the current demand of the country we will polluting Sri Lankan agricultural soils from
heavy metals in other countries.
Economic Losses:
 A simple calculation performed using yield loss estimates to assess its effects on
production, imports and exports, treating all the other factors are held at constant levels,
reveal that the effects of the ban on exports and imports are significant.
Using yield losses predicted by Sirisena et al. (2016), it was found that profitability of paddy
farming reduces by 32.7% and rice consumption reduces by 26.7% or rice imports increases
to LKR 10 billion if the conventional paddy fields are converted to organic cultivations. If
no fertilizer is available, reductions in profitability and rice consumption and will be as large
as 44.41% and 44.12% respectively. If the shortage is met by imports, rice import bill
increases to LKR 42 billion.
A reduction in tea productivity by 35% would lose foreign exchange by LKR 85 billion and
a reduction in coconut yields in 27% of lands will cause a reduction on Rs. 18 billion
respectively as per the estimates of Sri Lanka Agricultural Economics Association.
The effects on Other Filed Crops, vegetables, potato, floriculture etc. which use hybrid
varieties will be large. The less affected will be pulses due to their nitrogen fixing ability
and spices grown in home-gardens.
5
A general equilibrium analysis conducted for modest composite yield shocks to
accommodate all the adaptations by economic agents using a Global Trade Model (GTAP –
version 10) illustrate some significant economic effects even in the long run. Increases in
food prices, reductions in production of agriculture sub-sectors as well as processed food
sectors, increases in food imports, and reductions in agri-food exports are predicted by the
model. More specifically, a reduction in GDP by 2.65% owing to a 20% yield loss in crop
agriculture sectors is predicted. Overall, the economic growth will be retarded with
adverse implication on employment, rural economic activity, food security, poverty and
vulnerabilities.
Conclusion:
The immediate benefits of the import ban will be marginal and uncertain. Lifting of the ban
imposed with immediate effect would benefit the Sri Lankan economy.
Way Forward: (assuming that the ban is not be lifted)
(1) The approach of Good Agricultural Practices (GAP), which is in line with the above task is
strongly recommended to achieve the Green Agricultural Model through a gradual
transition.
The GAP is a practice that needs to be applied on the farm to ensure food safety during
the pre-production, production, harvest and post-harvest stages. In many cases, such
practices also contribute to protect the environment and safety of the workers. In other
words, GAP is a systematic approach that aims at applying available knowledge to address
environmental, economic and social sustainability dimensions of on-farm production and
post-production processes, resulting in safe and quality agricultural products.
The concept of Good Agriculture Practice (GAP) was introduced to Sri Lanka in 2012 with
the project Asian Food and Agriculture Cooperation Initiative (AFACI) and SL-GAP was
officially launched in 2015. The implementation of SL-GAP is presently being done by the
Department of Agriculture (DOA) and Provincial Departments of Agriculture (PDoA)
including the Mahawali extension systems.
Since 2015, the certification for GAP farms issued by the Department of Agriculture is in
accordance with the SLS 1523. SL-GAP follows codes of practices, considerations in acts
and regulations which help to improve food quality, food safety and sustainability of
agriculture including conservation of natural resources while enhancing the organic matter
production, improving workers welfare and safety, creating new market opportunities for
farmers and improving traceability.
These regulations have covered all aspects of soil, water, plant nutrition management,
crop protection practices, crop recording, worker health and hygiene, field sanitation,
postharvest practices, transportation, and storage etc., which are major elements of GAP.
6
(2) Addressing the challenges of nutrition in Sri Lanka through guiding Principles of Multistakeholder involvement in nutrition and health, Social determinants of nutrition and
Health, Evidence-Based approach, Quality assurance, monitoring and regulations and
Education and Capacity Building is strongly recommended
(3) Subsidy payment for chemical fertilizers needs to be revisited to promote locally produced
organic fertilizers to be applied in adequate quantities. These organic fertilizers needs to
be made available to all farmer fields at required times.
Quality of organic fertilizers should be improved so that slow nutrient release can be
predictable, contains high concentration of nutrients, flexibility to custom made nutrient
ratios to match with the soil-crop requirement. These organic fertilizers should be devoid
of any contaminants that could negatively affect human health and environment.
(4) Research and innovations should be strengthened to produce liquid and granule organic
fertilizers from locally available resources. Effective Bio-fertilizers, bio-stimulants, and
technologies to extract plant nutrients from wastes without contaminants should be
invented. These new technologies can be used to partially substitute imported chemical
fertilizers.
(5) Extension staff and Farmers should be educated with new technologies and possible
environmental and health issues that could be arisen due to indiscriminate use of plant
nutrients, whichever the source may be.
(6) Institutional and capacity building programme for the Department of Agriculture and the
Provincial Departments of Agriculture should be carried out giving special emphasis to
develop accredited laboratories at provincial level. Increase laboratory facilities for
nutrient testing, pesticide residue testing, heavy metal and microbial testing, Soil samples
and water sample testing is important while introducing mobile testing facility.
(7) Official linkages should be established and the Department of National Planning or the
Treasury should create a new fund flow arrangement from the Ministry of Agriculture or
Department of Agriculture to the University system.